General Actions:
Wiki: opencaselist13
▼:
Document Index
»
Space: Texas-San Antonio
▼:
Document Index
»
Page: Colwell-Robertson Neg
Tournament | Round | Opponent | Judge | Cites | Round Report | Open Source | Video | Edit/Delete |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bear Shock | 1 | Kansas FG | Matt Moore |
| ||||
KCKCC | 6 | Central Oklahoma BH | Morris, Eric |
| ||||
Las Vegas Classic | 4 | UT Dallas OV | Vitolo-Haddad, Christina |
| ||||
UCO | 6 | Baylor SW | Phil Samuels |
| ||||
UMKC | 4 | UNT AS | Scott Harris |
| ||||
Wake Forest | 8 | GSU FF | Max Archer |
|
Tournament | Round | Report |
---|
To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.
Entry | Date |
---|---|
Being-towards-death KTournament: UCO | Round: 6 | Opponent: Baylor SW | Judge: Phil Samuels Death, for Heidegger, is the possibility of the impossibility of existence. If The refusal to be authentic denies the responsibility for one’s freedom that is at the heart of ethics, perpetuating conflict, racism, and exploitation. Having set out some crucial ontological considerations, Linsenbard goes on to discuss some of Death is the basis of subjectivity and what makes our choices and lives meaningful. Each inauthentic response is a unique refusal to take on the task of making death our own. Death is the origin of subjectivity; our inwardness is touched to the quick by The affirmative’s concern with extinction is more than a pragmatic concern – it is an expression of existential anxiety. We ought to refuse politically polemic contestation in favor of an existential realization of anxiety. In line with the above thought, I have noted that world order scholars are Domesticating anxiety is the central function of imperialist metaphysics – it is a denial of difference that reduces every differential being it encounters to standing, disposable reserve. To put this reduction in the terms precipitated by the implicit distinction between two kinds In the face of anxiety there are two responses: tranquilization or openness. The affirmative is a return to the inauthentic existence of everydayness. The alternative is to embrace anxiety and take responsibility for our freedom. With respect to death, anxiety has a special disclosive capacity. As Heidegger claims | 1/5/14 |
Coloniality KTournament: UMKC | Round: 4 | Opponent: UNT AS | Judge: Scott Harris It is important … of world-system? Divorcing location and experience from the justifications of solutions to suffering justifies the management of suffering from the West and reproduces colonial power. People suffer.17 …¶ normalities of business-as-usual (Robinson and Tormey 2009). Empire operates through a fundamental re-ordering of space and time, privileging the imperial man as God-like, able to categorize and posses the world. This culminates in either the assimilation of the colonized through the internalization of oppression or the radical exclusion of the colonized from humanity in genocide. The proper recognition … and eat it too?“ The grammar of de-coloniality … as an-other paradigm. The role of the ballot is to embrace an ethics of opacity. Our ethics affirms that value and dignity of those who have been violently excluded from the hegemony of Western epistemology and interrupts the will to transparency that makes the genocidal violence of coloniality possible. The ethics of opacity … an ethics of opacity? | 9/15/13 |
Forgot About SpanosTournament: Bear Shock | Round: 1 | Opponent: Kansas FG | Judge: Matt Moore Spanos 08 William V. American Exceptionalism in the Age of Globalization. Pg 10-14 Derrida’s analysis constitutes a powerful and, however belated, much welcomed thematization not simply Imperialism is not just a way that states interact, but is also a relation to the world which maps and orders differences that can be accommodated to its logic and destroys anything that refuses assimilation. Any peace created by the benign gesture of the affirmative is based on the colonization of the Other, violence which is hidden through the imposition of imperialist metaphysics. The end of the pursuit of knowledge, according to this developed — postcolonial — The problems of the affirmative are not aberrations that can be corrected with a change in policy, a supposedly correct application of liberal democracy. The consolidation of power in the executive and the attendant excesses of this power are based in an exceptionalist ontology that justifies biopolitical control and destruction as the fulfillment of the project of liberal democracy. The reduction of beings to bare life culminates in the total devaluation of life, excluding those who undergo violence from consideration as an ethical being. The event of Auschwitz demands that one witness what happened there but the unbearable nature Securitization neutralizes politics and makes violence inevitable, leading to a worldwide civil war. Agamben 02 Giorgio. “Security and Terror,” Theory and event 5:4 Today we are facing extreme and most dangerous developments of this paradigm of security. Scholars and policymakers have forged America as a white democratic messiah – one who filters events through whiteness that renders racial difference irrational and necessitates that it must be violently controlled. This makes constant interventions which justify genocide inevitable. Martinot 03 Steve, lecturer at San Francisco State University in the Center for Interdisciplinary Programs, “The Cultural Roots of Interventionism in the US,” Social Justice Vol. 30, No. 1 (2003), pp. 19-20 In summary, U.S. interventionism has three structural elements that are homologous In the face of the affirmative’s demand, we give Bartleby’s response of “I would prefer not to.” We refuse to be answerable to the calls to recuperate the project of liberal democracy and American exceptionalism, exposing imperialist violence and opening the space to rethink politics and thinking. Spanos 2000 William, America’s Shadow, p 197-202 The role of the judge is to position yourself as an exilic intellectual and interrogate the assumptions and scholarship of the 1ac. This rethinking of the position of the intellectual is key to break down the cult of expertise and its complicity with imperialism. The recent resuscitation of the project of Empire should give International¶ Relations scholars particular | 2/26/14 |
Gift 1NCTournament: KCKCC | Round: 6 | Opponent: Central Oklahoma BH | Judge: Morris, Eric Enrique Dussel provides … from African descent. Giving the gift of emancipation creates a logic of possession, destroying the possibility of reciprocal exchange. Privileging the West as the liberator forces the damned to be dependent on the colonizer and justifies the dehumanization of the colonized. The decolonial gift … as we will see below. Thus, the alternative is to delink from the West in order to create alternatives to modernity. How does the body-politics … as an-other paradigm The role of the ballot is the ethics of generosity. Ethical relations to the other are only possible through a responsibility to the subaltern, which necessitates listening and following the lead of the damned. Therefore, the positionality of the damne must be the priority of our ethics, politics and epistemology in order to resist colonial power. Cartesianism introduces … vis-a-vis epistemic levels. | 10/30/13 |
Irigaray Love KTournament: Wake Forest | Round: 8 | Opponent: GSU FF | Judge: Max Archer And I knew when I entered her I was Greedy as herring-gulls Audre Lorde – Love Poem While feeling may not be missing from the affirmative, something essential is – the erotic touch, the feeling of being connected not only to our deepest emotions and bodily drives but to another person. The affirmative’s exclusion of the erotic means that they fail to recognize an essential source of resistance against racism, sexism, heteronormativity, and other forms of oppression. Audre Lorde writes, THERE ARE MANY kinds of power, used and unused, acknowl-¶ edged or The exclusion of erotic relations is not an accident - The struggle for identity and recognition assumes that we are all alienated subjects, which creates relationships of violence towards difference that attempts to fill a perceived gap between self and other. Emancipatory politics need an ethic of love to mobilize resistance and progressive movements. The alternative is a narcissism that denies the possibility of meaningful relationships, leaving only the possibility of hostility and violence. Kelly Oliver explains, There is a powerful resonance between hooks’s description of love as necessarily self-critical Oppression operates through the denial of the drives of the subject, rendering our emotions and affects meaningless as our psychic space is colonized. This leads to the internalization of oppression and the denial of agency. We must start with the colonization of the unconscious if we are to create a politics that can fight oppression. Affirming the poetic expression of erotic and other drives allows for us to make them meaningful and carve out a space for resistance. Oliver continues, Oliver 04 Kelly. W. Alton Jones Chair of Philosophy at Vanderbilt University. The Colonization of Psychic Space: A Psychoanalytic Theory of Oppression. Pg 127-30 Psychic space depends on the movement between drives and language or signification; that is Do not let you head deny Do not pretend to convenient beliefs Remember whatever pain you bring back Audre Lorde – For Each of You Our affirmation of our love to the affirmative recognizes the irreducibility of others, which allows for positive communication and relationships beyond domination. Such a potential requires an ethic of love that bridges the gap between self and other and avoids any assimilation of the object of love. Oliver explains, Irigaray suggests that we are different and that we can communicate because of what she Our alternative necessitates recognizing sexual difference as the ground of our existence. It is a recognition of our limitations and our relation to the other, which breaks down the narcissism of the affirmative. Anne Caldwell explains, How exactly does Irigaray understand the structure of subjectivity in light¶ of a sexed The role of the ballot is to vote for who presents the best methodology to liberate the oppressed. Only by accounting for the unconscious and otherness, that which is always beyond our understanding, allows for us to constantly question the social order and create ethical relationships. Our alternative is the best strategy for the psychic liberation of the oppressed through the sublimation of drives through poetry. Oliver expounds, Oliver 04 Kelly. W. Alton Jones Chair of Philosophy at Vanderbilt University. The Colonization of Psychic Space: A Psychoanalytic Theory of Oppression. Pg xxii-xxiv In the end, I argue that ethics—or, making politics ethical— | 1/5/14 |
Material Decolonializationor Decolonial Materialism, or whatever Heres a 1NCTournament: Las Vegas Classic | Round: 6 | Opponent: Weber St HH | Judge: Weitz, Mike Shooter Fighting empire without a commitment to the decolonization of the US leads to the continuation of settler colonialism. Not unique, the United States, as a settler colonial nation-state, The affirmative’s metaphorization of decolonization through mestiza consciousness renders them innocent, allowing for them to deny responsibility for their own participation in settler colonialism, maintaining the structure of oppression that they claim to fight. We observe that another component of a desire to play Indian is a settler desire Settler colonialism is the root cause of the aff’s impacts. "Indian Country" was/is the term used in Viet Nam, Afghanistan The alternative is to affirm the material decolonization of the United States. Having elaborated on settler moves to innocence, we give a synopsis of the imbrication The affirmation of the incommensurability of decolonization is essential to break down settler colonialism – any perm the permutation merely changes hierarchies without destroying them. Incommensurability is an acknowledgement that decolonization will require a change in the order of Focusing on changing mindsets to "decolonize the mind" is just another way to sidestep the demand for true decolonization and to avert the guilt associated with the affirmative’s participation in settler colonialism. Freire’s philosophies have encouraged educators to use "colonization" as a metaphor for The Western ideology on which fluid identity is justified allows the continuation of violence against indigenous peoples, following the West to its inevitable suicide. | 10/30/13 |
Standpoint BadTournament: Las Vegas Classic | Round: 4 | Opponent: UT Dallas OV | Judge: Vitolo-Haddad, Christina Perhaps the best example of how feminists may inadvertently reproduce and reinforce the "false We don’t even understand our own oppression or social location – there’s no such thing. Even if we did, standpoint theory alone fails b/c its circular when it comes to deciding which standpoints should be prioritized or privileged. Claims to rally around a unified social location are usually just masked attempts at retaining privilege. Criticisms of Feminist Standpoint Theory. Longino (1993b) argues that standpoint theory cannot Strict adherence to the idea that we can only speak from our own social locations is not empowering/liberating/emancipating, and it doesn’t solve. They straight-jacket dissent and colonize those who disagree. In discussing ’standpoints’, Wendell (1996), Pease (2000) and Hartsock As long as our representations aren’t violent, it’s ok to speak for others. To say that only individuals who have experienced certain things can speak about them is disempowering, leaves unequal power relations intact, places all the responsibility for alleviating oppression to the oppressed, and ensures that subjugated knowledges stay subjugated. This brings us to the conundrum of speaking for/with others. For many | 10/30/13 |
Universality 1NCTournament: Las Vegas Classic | Round: 4 | Opponent: UT Dallas OV | Judge: Vitolo-Haddad, Christina The attempt to … to postcolonial theory. Difference and otherness are simply what exists; it is meaningless outside of emancipatory projects. The respect for difference not only denies the possibility of transcending the situation of oppression, but creates the imperative to assimilate or destroy the other. Our suspicions are … more nor less. Basing ethics and politics on mere particularity, whether identities or relations, inevitably constructs enemies and demands their extermination. It is only through a fidelity to truth that we can avoid scapegoating and genocide. In the case of …directed at everyone. The alternative is to maintain a fidelity to truth. Inasmuch as … (or neighbours), and so on. The role of the ballot is the commitment to the universal act. Since ideology structures the way that we understand reality, we cannot rely on anything external to our ethical commitments, such as the suffering of others or fear of a greater evil, to give us our ethics, which would only reproduce the same ideology that makes the violence of the affirmative possible. Only through a total commitment to and responsibility for the universal maxim which stems from our truth can we maintain a true ethics and break down this ideology. 'Act so that … the ethical dimension proper. | 10/30/13 |
Filename | Date | Uploaded By | Delete |
---|
Air Force
Amherst
Appalachian State
Arizona State
Army
Augustana
Bard
Baylor
Binghamton
Boston College
Capital
CSU Long Beach
CSU Northridge
CSU Sacramento
CUNY
Cal Berkeley
Cal Lutheran
Cal Poly SLO
Case Western
Central Florida
Central Oklahoma
Chico
Clarion
Columbia
Concordia
Cornell
Dartmouth
Denver
Drexel-Swarthmore
ENMU
East Los Angeles College
Eastern Washington
Emory
Emporia
Fayetteville State
Florida
Florida Int'l
Florida State
Fordham
Fresno State
Fullerton
Gainesville State
George Mason
George Washington
Georgetown
Georgia
Georgia State
Georgia Tech
Gonzaga
Harvard
Houston
Idaho State
Illinois
Illinois State
Indiana
Iowa
Irvine/SFSU
James Madison
John Carroll
Johns Hopkins
Johnson County CC
KCKCC
Kansas
Kansas State
Kentucky
LA City College
Lakeland
Lewis-Clark State College
Liberty
Lindenwood
Los Rios
Louisville
Loyola
Macalester
Marist
Mary Washington
Mercer
Methodist
Miami FL
Miami OH
Michigan
Michigan State
Minnesota
Mission
Missouri State
NYU
Navy
New School
North Texas
Northern Iowa
Northwestern
Notre Dame
Ohio Wesleyan
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pepperdine
Piedmont
Pittsburgh
Portland State
Princeton
Puget Sound
Redlands
Richmond
Rochester
Rutgers
Samford
San Diego State
San Francisco State
Santa Clara
South Florida St Pete
Southern Methodist
Southwestern
Stanford
Texas State
Texas-Austin
Texas-Dallas
Texas-San Antonio
Texas-Tyler
Towson
Trinity
U Chicago
UCLA
UDC-CC
UMKC
UNLV
USC
Utah
Vanderbilt
Vermont
Virginia Tech
Wake Forest
Wash U (St. Louis)
Washburn
Washington
Wayne State
Weber
West Georgia
West Virginia
Western Connecticut
Whitman
Wichita State
Wisconsin Oshkosh
Wyoming