Tournament: 2013babyjo | Round: 3 | Opponent: Johnson County Community College Domme-Warren | Judge: St John
1NC Shell
Your affirmation is only a continuation of the never ending “war on terror”. Forgetting the first event makes the second event irrelevant. Forget the event, we have no “outlaws” to chase…
Roberto Ciccarelli, 2010 Conflict, Security and the Reshaping of Society : The Civilization of War Palidda , Salvatore ; Dal Lago , Alessandro 2010
Two events have revived the …….
s that regulate emergency situations.1
The naming of 9/11 is a dangerous act – it presupposes a supposedly universal
calendar – the affirmatives repetition is an attempt at neutralizing and distancing ourselves from the text of that day
Derrida 2003 interviewed in Philosophy in a time of terror by Giovanna Borradori – Online excerpt http://www.press.uchicago.edu/Misc/Chicago/066649.html
Le 11 septembre, as you say……
something about it.
Our criticism comes before the aff – in debates about framing 9/11 attentiveness to
language is necessary
Derrida 2003 interviewed in Philosophy in a time of terror by Giovanna Borradori – Online excerpt
http://www.press.uchicago.edu/Misc/Chicago/066649.html
I believe always ……"September 11, September
11, le 11 septembre, 9/11."
The institutional narrative of 9/11 overdetermines our ability to confront the empirical reality of the event allowing the memory to be deployed for political ends.
Zehfuss, 2003 (Maja – University of Manchester, “Forget September 11”, Third World Quarterly Vol. 24 No. 3)
We are under……. Empirical detail does not disturb it.
Invoking the narrative of 9/11 drives out all other alternatives of memory. This allows uncontested political interventionism to repay the suffering of those lost in the event.
Zehfuss, 2003 (Maja – University of Manchester, “Forget September 11”, Third World Quarterly Vol. 24 No. 3)
These important questions are not asked……’.86 It is this consideration of alternatives that has been lost.
Invoking the symbolic authority of the memory of September 11th creates a stop-gap in thinking precluding discussions of what is political or how we as subjects constitute our own identities. Instead we should forget 9/11 so we can remember ourselves.
Zehfuss, 2003 (Maja – University of Manchester, “Forget September 11”, Third World Quarterly Vol. 24 No. 3) Bush recommended t…….. in the name of the memory of the dead.
Your affirmation of the topic is part of the the post-9/11 educational project of the neoconservatives informed by an imperial binary logic which necessarily perceives its Other as a something or someone that must be annihilated.
SPANOS 6 William, professor of comp lit at SUNY Bing, “Humanism and the Studia Humanitatis after 9/11/01: Rethinking the Anthropologos,” symploke 13:1/2, 248-254
FROM THE TIME ……. OF GETTING AND SPENDING IN THE GLOBAL MARKET.